Immanuel Lutheran Church, Mankato
St. Paul—His Life and Letters
Paul’s Letter to the Galatians – Part III
XIII. Paul’s Letter to the Galatians – Part III
An interesting question arises in connection with Galatians 5:11. Apparently, the false teachers in Galatia were saying that Paul, too, taught that you had to be circumcised even though he had not done so while in Galatia. What evidence would they have cited to support their claim? Those who feel that the letter to the Galatians was written during the Third Missionary Journey point to the fact that in Acts 16:1-5 Paul had Timothy circumcised so as not to offend the Jews. This was done as a matter of Christian liberty. The false teachers, however, could have easily misinterpreted that action as meaning Paul did actually teach circumcision.
We, however, as mentioned earlier (cf. Note 45) have assumed that the letter was written prior to the Second Missionary Journey either before or while on the way to the Jerusalem Council depicted in Acts 15. The actions of Paul with regard to Timothy would then have not yet occurred. Upon what would the false teachers have based their claim? This leads us to a consideration of the incident described by Paul in Galatians 2:1-5, in which Paul states that, "Not even Titus who was with me, being a Greek, was compelled to be circumcised." Most Bible scholars have assumed that what Paul means is that Titus was not circumcised—that Paul in fact used Titus as his "test case" to prove that believers did not need to be circumcised. But is this necessarily so? Notice that Paul does not say that Titus was "not circumcised," but rather that he was "not compelled to be circumcised." It is quite probable that Titus was circumcised willingly and as a matter of Christian freedom for the very same reason that Paul later circumcised Timothy—to avoid possible offense. The section would then mean that when the Jews attempted to use Titus as an example that circumcision was in fact necessary, Paul refused to yield this point in any way so as to protect the liberty of other Gentile believers. The false teachers in Galatia could have pointed to Titus as support for their false claim, thus making it necessary for Paul to explain the situation in Galatians 2:1-5 and 5:11 .
Discussion Topics: